There is a serious flaw with the suggestion mobile radios be wired across battery terminals. The negative radio lead should actually not have a fuse, and not be wired to the battery post.
History of Vehicle Accessory Equipment Grounds
Early vehicles had both positive and negative grounds. USA passenger vehicles evolved, standardizing on "12 volt" negative ground systems. The resting voltage was around 12.6 volts, with ideal running voltage in the low 14 volt range. Many large commercial vehicles, however, retained positive grounds. Non-standardization of systems meant two-way radios and other add on equipment was generally designed to operate with either negative or positive grounds. This was accomplished by floating the internal negative supply buss, while grounding all normally accessible external user ports to the case or cabinet.
These early systems started the trend of negative fuses, with both power leads directly attached to the battery. This was not harmful, because the equipment had a completely isolated internal "ground " that was electrically isolated from all other leads leaving the device.
Once any other lead common with the negative bus leaves the case, it is no longer safe to conned the negative to the battery post. It is also not safe to fuse the negative lead.
In most early CB and commercial two-way radios, the negative buss inside the unit fully floated from the cabinet and any external ports. This included commercial two-way radios like the Motorola Motrac, Micor, and other expensive, high-quality, radios. The floating negative was universal across brands including, but not limited to, GE and RCA land mobile equipment.
The floating negative allowed use of radios in either negative or positive ground vehicles. It also solved ground loop issues, allowing direct connection to battery posts without fire or equipment damage hazards.
Equipment manufacturers had no way of knowing if the final installation would be in a negative ground vehicle or a positive ground vehicle. As a result, systems with a floating negative buss were shipped with both negative and positive power line fuses. The floating negative buss system inside the radio allowed safe direct connection to the battery posts, and safe shutdown if either the positive or negative fuse opened.
The floating negative power buss made it impossible for starter or charging currents to flow through antenna cables, microphone, or speaker leads. All exiting connections, as well as the case, were electrically isolated from the negative lead.
Negative Ground Only Equipment and Radios
Over time, vehicles with positive grounds disappeared. As this happened, manufacturers stopped using the more-expensive and more-complicated floating negative power bus system.
Many vehicle manufacturers, and most aftermarket equipment manufacturers, never re-thought the systems others were using. Manufacturers carried over the acceptable negative fuse idea appearing in ground independent power buss systems, which could also use a negative battery post connection. Manufacturers misapplied the allowable fused negative battery post connection to equipment with internally grounded negative bus systems.
Not realizing the safety hazard, they continued to fuse both negative and positive radio power leads and often advised direct battery post negative connections. The battery post connection actually created ground loop, fire, and equipment safety hazards.
This terrible idea has permeated the aftermarket accessory market, including amateur radio, audio, and performance or race car electronics markets. For example, MSD Ignition's installation instructions advise a direct battery post negative connection, putting the vehicle's distributor, the MSD box, and other electronics at risk.
Although absolutely incorrect, a popular assumption is fusing the negative lead can protect internal and external equipment wiring, including gauge, computer, speaker, microphone, key leads, and antenna connections from open battery ground connection damage.
|The only battery post negative connection should be to or from another battery negative, the vehicle chassis, and/or the engine block. There should never be a direct negative post path to accessory equipment.|
Normal vehicle wiring is shown and discussed in detail on this page link.
Follow the current in this system....
If the ground or negative wire from the radio to the battery opens, radio current would flow from the radio out through the antenna cable, the speaker jack, the key jack, or any other jack or connector that connects to the radio circuit board grounds to the vehicle chassis.
If the battery to engine block ground opens, or the engine block and battery to chassis grounds open, the battery will ground back through the negative radio connection to the radio, through circuit boards or other connections, and to the vehicle chassis.
While a radio negative lead fuse will protect higher current circuits, it will not protect small traces or components like those connected to insulated jacks or connectors.
For example, when my radio system lost a negative fuse connection, foil traces for the keyer paddle grounds inside my ICOM 751A burned open. I could no longer send CW.
The traces opened even though the negative lead was fused, because the radio's transmitter current of ~20 amperes flowed through small circuit board traces to my CW key. The CW key was grounded by touching a metal bracket, and this melted foil traces on a circuit board inside the radio. With a grounded negative buss and battery post connection:
Connecting the radio or accessory equipment's grounded negative supply does nothing good. Grounding to the battery negative post generally increases alternator whine. It also places the vehicle's computer and electrical system at higher risk, is unsafe for the radio or accessory, and is unsafe for things connected to the radio.
I've had vehicles with higher power radios that have opened a negative fuse, and then melted the coaxial cable shield on RG58/U cables. This is because, once the fuse connection was lost, the equipment grounded itself to the vehicle chassis through the grounded antenna cables.
Correcting the Ground
It is pretty simple to improve the grounding system.
If we ground the radio negative lead to a separate but good chassis ground near the battery ground, ground loops through the vehicle's computer system, through the radio, and through anything connected to the radio or accessory, are completely avoided.
Ideally, this ground should not share the bolt that grounds the battery to chassis ground cable. The negative power ground should be on its own bolt. The fasteners should be good hardware, with proper star washers. The ground must provide solid, reliable, mechanical and electrical connections.
If the radio or accessory device's chassis power ground lead opens, only radio or accessory current will flow through the radio circuit boards. While this may still open a trace, it is much less likely to happen because we have eliminated a needless weak point, the negative fuse, and we have eliminated the direct connection to the battery where battery acid slowly eats away at connections.
A vehicle chassis power ground completely eliminates the current path through the radio or accessory if the engine block ground battery lead opens, and alternator AC ripple no longer can drive the negative lead to the radio. Any connection can fail, and in the very worse case possible we have only radio operating current. In most cases, we will not even have that.
It also helps to have multiple ground points as additional insurance against the negative power lead accidentally floating.
Who Else Agrees with Me?
Mobile radio installation standards agree:
Published standards specifically tell us to not ground to the battery post, and not to fuse the negative lead!
|4.6.4. Negative Feed Connection
In the case of negative earth return vehicles, the negative power line should not be fused. It should be
connected to the vehicle body as close as practical to the point at which the battery-to-body connection is
made. Do not connect the negative power line directly to the battery.
For heavy commercial vehicles (>7.5Tonne GVW) only, and those vehicles with tilting cabs where the
cab may be isolated from the chassis by rubber mountings, a ground point is provided by the vehicle
manufacturer within the cab to provide battery to cab grounding. Generally this is located within the main
fuse box. It is recommended that this point be used for installations in this instance.
With certain equipment it may be necessary to connect the negative supply line to a local earth point. In
this case an existing vehicle earth point must be used.
Motorola manuals for radios without an internal floating negative buss tell us the following:
Motorola warns to not use a negative fuse or battery negative post connection, but rather directly connect the negative lead to the vehicle chassis.
Only the positive lead is fused.
Only the positive lead goes to the battery post.